**Disclosure: This post may contain affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
If Satan’s Affair left you wanting something chaotic, bloody, obsessive, and completely unhinged, you are not alone.
This is not the kind of dark romance where the danger stays neatly in the background.
Readers who love Satan’s Affair usually want:
- morally black characters
- carnival, cult, horror, or revenge vibes
- obsessive attraction
- violent tension
- “should I be reading this?” energy
- female rage, masked men, monsters, killers, or villains
- books that feel more like a dark ride than a cozy romance
So this list is for readers who want that same disturbing, addictive, no-brakes energy — but with different books than the ones already used in my other dark romance lists.
Before going in, check trigger warnings for every book. These are dark romance, horror romance, villain romance, and extreme romance recommendations. Many include violence, trauma, dubcon/noncon themes, captivity, stalking, murder, cults, gore, or psychologically intense content.
Quick Ranking System
Spice Level:
1 = mild tension
5 = very explicit / high heat
Darkness Level:
1 = moody but manageable
5 = extreme / check every trigger warning first
1. The Contortionist
Author: Kathryn Ann Kingsley
Why readers love it:
This is one of the best picks for readers who liked the eerie carnival energy of Satan’s Affair but want something more fantasy-horror and villain-centered. The Harrow Faire setting feels creepy, theatrical, strange, and dangerous in the exact way dark carnival readers crave.
Simon is not a soft hero. He is manipulative, theatrical, obsessive, and completely morally wrong — which makes him perfect for readers who love villain romance.
Spice level: 3/5
Darkness level: 4/5
Trigger warnings: Violence, manipulation, body horror elements, captivity themes, psychological darkness.
Best for readers who liked: Creepy carnival settings, villain heroes, obsessive tension, and morally black love interests.
2. The Puppeteer
Author: Kathryn Ann Kingsley
Why readers love it:
This continues the Harrow Faire chaos and leans even deeper into dangerous attraction. If you loved the feeling of being trapped inside a twisted attraction where every character is a little wrong, this series delivers that.
The romance is not safe, sweet, or normal. It feels like being pulled further into a haunted carnival where the villain is the prize and the punishment.
Spice level: 3/5
Darkness level: 4/5
Trigger warnings: Manipulation, violence, psychological control, dangerous romance dynamics.
Best for readers who liked: Unstable villains, creepy circus/carnival worlds, and slow-burn obsession.
3. The Impossible Julian Strande
Author: Kathryn Ann Kingsley
Why readers love it:
This one is gothic, ghostly, obsessive, and seductive in a very strange way. Julian is charming, dangerous, manipulative, and impossible to fully trust — which is exactly why readers get hooked.
It is less bloody than Satan’s Affair, but the atmosphere is dark, haunted, and morally questionable.
Spice level: 3/5
Darkness level: 3.5/5
Trigger warnings: Ghostly possession themes, manipulation, death, emotional control, gothic horror elements.
Best for readers who liked: Charming villains, haunted-house vibes, and romance that feels cursed.
4. Her Soul to Take
Author: Harley Laroux
Why readers love it:
This is for readers who want the occult, ritualistic, demon-filled side of dark romance. It has cult energy, horror atmosphere, possession-adjacent tension, and a demon love interest who is dangerous but addictive.
If Satan’s Affair worked for you because of the mix of horror and spice, this is a strong next read.
Spice level: 5/5
Darkness level: 4/5
Trigger warnings: Cults, demons, violence, ritual themes, stalking, blood, religious horror elements.
Best for readers who liked: Occult romance, demons, horror spice, and morally grey supernatural heroes.
5. Her Soul for Revenge
Author: Harley Laroux
Why readers love it:
This book brings heavier revenge energy. It is angry, dark, violent, and emotionally intense. The heroine has a sharp edge, and the romance feels like it belongs in a world where pain and power are tangled together.
Readers who loved the revenge-and-bloodshed side of Satan’s Affair may connect with this one.
Spice level: 5/5
Darkness level: 4.5/5
Trigger warnings: Violence, trauma, revenge, cult themes, blood, demons, dark sexual content.
Best for readers who liked: Vengeful heroines, occult danger, brutal backstories, and high-heat horror romance.
6. Losers: Part I
Author: Harley Laroux
Why readers love it:
This is chaotic, taboo, high-heat, and built around characters who do not fit into clean little boxes. It has outsider energy, emotional intensity, humiliation themes, and a group dynamic that feels messy in the best way.
It is not a carnival horror story, but it does have that same “this is too much and I cannot stop reading” pull.
Spice level: 5/5
Darkness level: 4/5
Trigger warnings: Bullying history, humiliation kink, group romance, trauma, explicit sexual content, power dynamics.
Best for readers who liked: Taboo tension, chaotic found-family darkness, and extreme spice.
7. Fairydale
Author: Veronica Lancet
Why readers love it:
This is gothic, twisted, atmospheric, and strange. It has mystery, obsession, darkness, and the kind of dreamy nightmare feeling that works well for readers who like their romance unsettling.
If you want something that feels like a haunted fairytale with teeth, Fairydale is a strong pick.
Spice level: 4/5
Darkness level: 4/5
Trigger warnings: Violence, trauma, obsession, gothic horror elements, dark family secrets.
Best for readers who liked: Gothic romance, cursed towns, obsessive love, and eerie atmosphere.
8. Morally Corrupt
Author: Veronica Lancet
Why readers love it:
This is a good pick for readers who want morally black characters and dangerous loyalty. The title says exactly what kind of book this is. It is not trying to give you a clean hero or a gentle romance.
It has crime, obsession, danger, and the kind of morally messy relationship that dark romance readers either love or run from.
Spice level: 4/5
Darkness level: 4/5
Trigger warnings: Violence, mafia/crime themes, murder, manipulation, morally dark characters.
Best for readers who liked: Villain couples, morally black romance, dangerous devotion, and crime-heavy plots.
9. Blood Orange
Author: Karina Halle
Why readers love it:
This is a dark vampire romance with gothic sensuality, obsession, danger, and a seductive villainous edge. It is dramatic, bloody, and atmospheric without feeling like a standard paranormal romance.
Readers who like the theatrical darkness of Satan’s Affair may enjoy the lush, dangerous feel here.
Spice level: 5/5
Darkness level: 4/5
Trigger warnings: Blood, violence, vampire themes, obsession, death, dark sexual content.
Best for readers who liked: Gothic paranormal romance, vampires, villainous seduction, and bloody romance.
10. Black Sunshine
Author: Karina Halle
Why readers love it:
This one blends vampires, obsession, kidnapping energy, danger, and dark sensuality. It is a paranormal romance, but it has enough edge to appeal to readers who want something more dangerous than soft vampire fiction.
It is a good “next step” if you like your romance supernatural, intense, and a little threatening.
Spice level: 4/5
Darkness level: 3.5/5
Trigger warnings: Kidnapping themes, blood, violence, vampire danger, trauma.
Best for readers who liked: Dark vampire romance, forced proximity, danger, and supernatural obsession.
11. River of Shadows
Author: Karina Halle
Why readers love it:
This is for readers who like death, myth, darkness, and romance that feels otherworldly. The setting has an underworld quality, and the romance leans into danger, power, and forbidden attraction.
It is a strong pick for readers who want something dark and fantasy-heavy after Satan’s Affair.
Spice level: 4/5
Darkness level: 4/5
Trigger warnings: Death themes, violence, monsters, grief, dark fantasy elements.
Best for readers who liked: Underworld romance, death gods, gothic fantasy, and dangerous supernatural heroes.
12. Land of the Beautiful Dead
Author: R. Lee Smith
Why readers love it:
This is not a quick, easy dark romance. It is bleak, emotional, disturbing, and unforgettable. The romance is wrapped in horror, death, decay, and impossible moral choices.
If Satan’s Affair gave you a taste for romance that does not feel safe, this is a much heavier, more literary-feeling option.
Spice level: 3/5
Darkness level: 5/5
Trigger warnings: Death, plague-like horror, body horror, violence, grief, disturbing imagery, power imbalance.
Best for readers who liked: Extremely dark atmosphere, monster romance, emotional devastation, and morally complex love stories.
13. The Scholomance
Author: R. Lee Smith
Why readers love it:
This is dark fantasy horror with extreme content, dangerous magic, monsters, and brutal survival energy. It is not a soft romance recommendation. It is for readers who want something disturbing, intense, and deeply weird.
Only pick this up if you are comfortable with very dark content.
Spice level: 4/5
Darkness level: 5/5
Trigger warnings: Extreme violence, monsters, noncon/dubcon themes, horror, death, disturbing sexual content.
Best for readers who liked: Extreme dark fantasy, horror romance, monster worlds, and books that go way past comfort zones.
14. Hollow Heathens
Author: Nicole Fiorina
Why readers love it:
This book gives dark, gothic, cursed-town energy with romance, secrets, and a haunting atmosphere. It is less murder-carnival chaos and more moody, witchy, and emotionally dark.
If you liked the strange, ritualistic side of Satan’s Affair, this is a good atmospheric follow-up.
Spice level: 3/5
Darkness level: 3.5/5
Trigger warnings: Curses, trauma, grief, violence, dark magic, family secrets.
Best for readers who liked: Witchy towns, gothic romance, curses, and moody dark academia-style atmosphere.
15. Bone Island
Author: Nicole Fiorina
Why readers love it:
This continues the dark, atmospheric, gothic feeling with more secrets, emotional tension, and eerie romance. It is a strong choice for readers who want something haunting instead of purely violent.
It works especially well for readers who want the darkness of Satan’s Affair but with more mystery and cursed-romance energy.
Spice level: 3/5
Darkness level: 3.5/5
Trigger warnings: Death, grief, curses, violence, emotional trauma, gothic suspense.
Best for readers who liked: Haunted settings, cursed love, gothic secrets, and dark romantic mystery.
Best Books Like Satan’s Affair by Vibe
If you want creepy carnival energy
Start with The Contortionist or The Puppeteer.
If you want occult horror and spice
Start with Her Soul to Take or Her Soul for Revenge.
If you want villain romance
Start with The Impossible Julian Strande, Fairydale, or Morally Corrupt.
If you want vampires and blood
Start with Blood Orange or Black Sunshine.
If you want extreme dark fantasy
Start with Land of the Beautiful Dead or The Scholomance.
If you want gothic witchy atmosphere
Start with Hollow Heathens or Bone Island.
What to Read After Satan’s Affair
If you finished Satan’s Affair and want another book with that same dangerous, unhinged feeling, your best first picks are:
- The Contortionist by Kathryn Ann Kingsley
- Her Soul to Take by Harley Laroux
- Fairydale by Veronica Lancet
- Blood Orange by Karina Halle
- Land of the Beautiful Dead by R. Lee Smith
Those five give you the strongest mix of horror, obsession, violence, atmosphere, and morally questionable romance.
More Dark Romance Reading Lists
If you want even more twisted recommendations, check out these next:
- Dark Romance Books Like Little Stranger
- Books Like God of Malice
- Dark Romance Books With Breeding Kink
- Books Like Does It Hurt?
- Dark Romance Books With Jealous Possessive Heroes
- Dark Romance Books Where He Falls First
- Free Dark Romance Books You Can Read Right Now (No Signup, No Paywall)
- Best Dark Romance Books of All Time (Ultimate Guide for Obsessive Readers)
You can also read my own dark romance fiction here:
He Was My Brother’s Best Friend First-
https://eerieefficiency.com/he-was-my-brothers-best-friend-first/
What Breaks You – https://eerieefficiency.com/spicy-fiction-18-eerie-efficiency-after-dark/
FAQ: Books Like Satan’s Affair
What kind of book is Satan’s Affair?
Satan’s Affair is a dark romance / horror romance novella with revenge, violence, obsession, carnival-style atmosphere, and morally dark characters. It is not a soft romance and should be approached with trigger warnings in mind.
What should I read after Satan’s Affair?
If you want the closest atmosphere, try The Contortionist by Kathryn Ann Kingsley. If you want occult spice, try Her Soul to Take by Harley Laroux. If you want something darker and more extreme, try Land of the Beautiful Dead by R. Lee Smith.
Are these books as dark as Satan’s Affair?
Some are darker, some are more gothic or fantasy-based. The Scholomance and Land of the Beautiful Dead are among the darkest on this list. Hollow Heathens and Bone Island are more atmospheric and gothic.
Do these books have spice?
Yes, many of them do. The highest-spice picks on this list are Her Soul to Take, Her Soul for Revenge, Losers: Part I, and Blood Orange.
Are these books safe for beginner dark romance readers?
Not all of them. If you are newer to dark romance, start with The Impossible Julian Strande, Hollow Heathens, or Black Sunshine. If you already read extreme dark romance, try The Scholomance or Land of the Beautiful Dead.
Do I need to read trigger warnings?
Yes. Absolutely. These books include dark themes, violence, obsession, trauma, horror, and intense sexual content. Always check author or retailer trigger warnings before reading.
Final Thoughts
If Satan’s Affair worked for you, you probably are not looking for a clean, safe, predictable romance.
You want danger.
You want obsession.
You want characters who should probably be avoided in real life but are impossible to stop reading about.
These books deliver that same dark-romance adrenaline in different ways — some through carnival horror, some through demons, some through gothic villains, vampires, cursed towns, or full-blown dark fantasy nightmares.
Start with The Contortionist if you want the carnival atmosphere.
Start with Her Soul to Take if you want occult spice.
Start with Land of the Beautiful Dead if you want something that will emotionally ruin you.
And if you want more dark romance recommendations, keep going through the dark romance reading guides above — because this rabbit hole gets darker fast.
2 Responses