Cottonwood by R. Lee Smith book cover
Last information check:
?An automated source lookup or an editor’s sourced check was recorded on this date. A lookup may have found no match. This does not mean all Eerie ratings, tropes, content warnings or Kindle Unlimited availability were reverified. Field verification is shown separately.
Eerie Efficiency Book Profile

Cottonwood

HEA Readable on its own: recorded 2013 Adult
About this book

They never meant to come to Earth. They were never allowed to leave...Welcome to Cottonwood.Excerpt:"You should have heard it, Kate. It was subtle, but it wasn't my imagination. The guy spent five hours essentially telling us that the aliens are retarded.""Oh come on.""Not in so many words, but--hang on." Sarah moved the paz to her other hand so that she could lay her right arm over Fagin's back, since he was being insistent about it. "But he just really drilled it in," she continued, resigned. "Over and over, really soft and gentle. 'They're not smart, they don't take care of themselves, they need to be controlled.'"Kate's tiny image on the screen flickered as she shifted her own paz and had trouble restabilizing. The two weren't exactly compatible anymore. She really needed to get a new one. "So? Maybe they do.""And maybe they don't. Kate!" she said, trying to laugh through her frustration. "These people came to us in a spaceship! A planet full of stupid layabouts does not master intergalactic space travel!"Kate's image flickered again and snapped to black. She didn't need it. She could hear the distraction in Kate's voice, and the tight I'm-pretending-I'm-not-angry tone that had been her default setting pretty much since Sarah told her she was really moving to Cottonwood. "Okay, so the guy who's been studying them for twenty years is wrong and Sarah Fowler, who hasn't even met one yet, is right. Congratulations. You're that good."Sarah felt herself blush. "It didn't sound right, that's all I'm saying. Some of the little things he said just...just really got to me.""Like what?" Kate asked, sounding concerned now and not big-sister patronizing."Like...Like he said that if their claspers came off, they'd die."A short pause. "What are claspers?""Oh, that's not the point, they're like tiny little extra arms that smell things. The point is, how many aliens had to lose their claspers and die without having any other...What's the word I want? Variables?"Kate was quiet for a while. The picture tried to come back a few times, showing Sarah glimpses of her sister through a haze of multi-colored distortion. "These guys are professionals, Sarah. It's their job to make connections that people like us miss.""Yeah, but how did so many aliens lose their claspers in the first place, that's what I really want to--""Did your house come with a phone?""Huh? Um, yeah." She twisted to look up at it, clinging to the wall like a shiny, black beetle. "But it's patched into the IBI switchboard. I can't figure out how to get a line outside the village. I could look it up in the manual, but--" She laughed. "--I'm kind of manualed-out. I had to set everything, you have no idea. All the faucets are TruTouch. Who the heck even knows off-hand how many degrees they like their shower? Or their drinking water? Plus, I got my Fahrenheit and my Celsius screwed up and practically steamed-cooked my face off the first time I...Why?" She checked the paz's signal, but it looked good. "Can't you hear me okay?""I hear you. I was just curious. So this is your own paz?""Yeah," said Sarah, still trying to see where this was going. "But they scanned it in through the company server when I got here. You know. So I can't take pictures or blog about company policy or stuff. They said it wouldn't affect my performance. I mean, I can barely see you, but--""That's normal for the fossil you're using," Kate agreed. In a new, hearty voice, she added, "TruTouch faucets, those are awesome!"

Description supplied by Google Books; not an Eerie editorial review. View source
View on Amazon ↗

Affiliate link — I may earn a commission. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

Best for readers who like: Homebound, The Last Hour of Gann, political alien romance
What do these ratings mean?

These are Eerie's editorial scores. Spice is scored out of 5; the other scores are out of 10. Higher intensity does not mean a better book. Romance Focus measures how central the relationship is to the story. Overall Recommendation is Eerie's recommendation for the book's intended readers.

Read the full rating methodology

Spice3/5
Darkness9/10
Obsession8/10
Psychological10/10
Violence9/10
Emotional Damage10/10
Trigger Intensity10/10
Romance Focus9/10

Bibliographic Sources

Source records for this Book. Automatic source checks do not verify Eerie ratings, tropes or content warnings.

Book at a Glance

Readable on its ownyes
POVThird Person
PaceSlow
Story LengthVery Long
EndingAmbiguous / Bittersweet • HEA
WorldSci-Fi / Alien
SettingRural / Wilderness
RelationshipM/F
Obsession TypeProtective Obsession • Romantic Fixation
SubgenreDark social science-fiction romance
MMC TypeProtector
Writing StyleEmotional / Angsty • Literary / Lyrical
MMC PersonalityGentle, intelligent, traumatized, protective, devoted father
FMC PersonalityIdealistic, compassionate, stubborn, empathetic, increasingly radicalized

Tropes & Themes

Trigger Warnings

These tags describe potentially sensitive material in the book and may not be a complete list. A missing warning does not confirm that the content is absent. HEA/HFN describes the romantic ending, not the absence of disturbing content. Check the author's current content notes before reading.

child endangermentgraphic violenceinstitutional abuseinternmentmedical abusemurderoppressionsexual violencetorturexenophobia

Eerie Take

Overall Recommendation10/10
Help keep Eerie accurate.Reader reports are reviewed before anything is changed.
Book vs BookPut this title beside another Eerie Book and compare editorial ratings, tropes, endings, and content notes.
Compare This Book
Personal content guidance

Can I Handle This Book?

Log in so Eerie can privately compare this book's verified darkness, spice, obsession, violence, triggers, and ending with your Reading DNA.

Separate reader consensus

Eerie Ratings vs Reader Ratings

Eerie’s editorial intensity scores never change because readers vote. Community averages are calculated separately from voluntary public submissions.

Reader enjoymentNo votes yet0 public ratings
Intensity
Eerie editorial
Readers
Spice
3/5
Waiting for votes
Darkness
9/10
Waiting for votes
Obsession
8/10
Waiting for votes
Psychological Intensity
10/10
Waiting for votes
Violence
9/10
Waiting for votes
Emotional Damage
10/10
Waiting for votes
Trigger Intensity
10/10
Waiting for votes
Romance Focus
9/10
Waiting for votes
Add your reader ratingLog in to submit one anonymous, editable community vote for this book.
Log In to Rate

Community totals never display a reader’s name, email, shelves, private star rating, notes, DNF history, or Reading DNA. One account gets one editable vote per book.

Your private reading record

Save to My Eerie Library

Track your reading status, progress, ownership, favorites, rating, dates, rereads, and private notes.

Help Eerie stay accurate

See something wrong?

Eerie ID

Reports enter a private editorial review queue. Nothing you submit changes a Book automatically.

Your dark romance companion

Keep Eerie on your home screen

Install Eerie Efficiency through your browser. Your existing account works here; you may need to sign in again in the app.

iPhone or iPad

  1. Open this site in Safari.
  2. Open the Share menu, then choose Add to Home Screen.
  3. If shown, leave Open as Web App enabled, then tap Add.

Android

Open this site in Chrome. Tap the browser menu, then Install app or Add to Home screen, if available.

Computer

In Chrome or Edge, look for the install icon near the address bar, or use the browser’s app installation menu. Options vary by browser.

If you opened Eerie inside Facebook, Instagram or another app, first open it in Safari or Chrome.

Books, searches, quizzes and your library need an internet connection. Your private reading information is not saved for offline viewing.