Kidnapped by the Pirate by Keira Andrews book cover
Last information check:
?An automated source lookup or an editor’s sourced check was recorded on this date. A lookup may have found no match. This does not mean all Eerie ratings, tropes, content warnings or Kindle Unlimited availability were reverified. Field verification is shown separately.
Eerie Efficiency Book Profile

Kidnapped by the Pirate

HEA Readable on its own: recorded 2017 Adult
About this book

Will a virgin captive surrender to this pirate’s sinful touch? Nathaniel Bainbridge is used to hiding, whether it’s concealing his struggles with reading or his forbidden desire for men. Under the thumb of his controlling father, the governor of Primrose Isle, he’s sailing to the fledging colony, where he’ll surrender to a respectable marriage for his family’s financial gain. Then pirates strike and he’s kidnapped for ransom by the Sea Hawk, a legendary villain of the New World. Bitter and jaded, Hawk harbors futile dreams of leaving the sea for a quiet life, but men like him don’t deserve peace. He has a score to settle with Nathaniel’s father—the very man whose treachery forced him into piracy—and he’s sure Nathaniel is just as contemptible. Yet as days pass in close quarters, Nathaniel’s feisty spirit and alluring innocence beguile and bewitch. Although Hawk knows he must keep his distance, the desire to teach Nathaniel the pleasure men can share grows uncontrollable. It’s not as though Hawk would ever feel anything for him besides lust… Nathaniel realizes the fearsome Sea Hawk’s reputation is largely invented, and he sees the lonely man beneath the myth, willingly surrendering to his captor body and soul. As a pirate’s prisoner, he is finally free to be his true self. The crew has been promised the ransom Nathaniel will bring, yet as danger mounts and the time nears to give him up, Hawk’s biggest battle could be with his own heart. This May-December gay romance from Keira Andrews features classic tropes including: a tough alpha pirate too afraid to love, a plucky virgin captive half his age, enemies to lovers, first-time sexual discovery, and of course a happy ending.

Description supplied by Google Books; not an Eerie editorial review. View source
View on Amazon ↗

Affiliate link — I may earn a commission. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

Best for readers who like: Captive Prince–style tension, historical MM romance, pirate adventure
What do these ratings mean?

These are Eerie's editorial scores. Spice is scored out of 5; the other scores are out of 10. Higher intensity does not mean a better book. Romance Focus measures how central the relationship is to the story. Overall Recommendation is Eerie's recommendation for the book's intended readers.

Read the full rating methodology

Spice4/5
Darkness5/10
Obsession7/10
Psychological6/10
Violence6/10
Emotional Damage7/10
Trigger Intensity6/10
Romance Focus10/10

Bibliographic Sources

Source records for this Book. Automatic source checks do not verify Eerie ratings, tropes or content warnings.

Book at a Glance

Readable on its ownyes
POVDual POV • Third Person
PaceMedium
Story LengthStandard
EndingHEA
WorldHistorical
RelationshipM/M
Obsession TypeCaptivity / Control
SubgenreHistorical MM pirate romance
MMC TypeAlpha / Dominant • Captor / Controlling
FMC TypeCaptive / Abducted • Innocent / Inexperienced
Writing StyleEmotional / Angsty
MMC PersonalityBitter, jaded, commanding, protective, lonely
FMC PersonalityPlucky, sheltered, intelligent, innocent, quietly defiant

Tropes & Themes

Trigger Warnings

These tags describe potentially sensitive material in the book and may not be a complete list. A missing warning does not confirm that the content is absent. HEA/HFN describes the romantic ending, not the absence of disturbing content. Check the author's current content notes before reading.

age gapcontrolling parentexplicit sexual contenthomophobiaKidnapping for ransommaritime dangerpower imbalanceviolence

Eerie Take

Overall Recommendation9/10
Help keep Eerie accurate.Reader reports are reviewed before anything is changed.
Book vs BookPut this title beside another Eerie Book and compare editorial ratings, tropes, endings, and content notes.
Compare This Book
Personal content guidance

Can I Handle This Book?

Log in so Eerie can privately compare this book's verified darkness, spice, obsession, violence, triggers, and ending with your Reading DNA.

Separate reader consensus

Eerie Ratings vs Reader Ratings

Eerie’s editorial intensity scores never change because readers vote. Community averages are calculated separately from voluntary public submissions.

Reader enjoymentNo votes yet0 public ratings
Intensity
Eerie editorial
Readers
Spice
4/5
Waiting for votes
Darkness
5/10
Waiting for votes
Obsession
7/10
Waiting for votes
Psychological Intensity
6/10
Waiting for votes
Violence
6/10
Waiting for votes
Emotional Damage
7/10
Waiting for votes
Trigger Intensity
6/10
Waiting for votes
Romance Focus
10/10
Waiting for votes
Add your reader ratingLog in to submit one anonymous, editable community vote for this book.
Log In to Rate

Community totals never display a reader’s name, email, shelves, private star rating, notes, DNF history, or Reading DNA. One account gets one editable vote per book.

Your private reading record

Save to My Eerie Library

Track your reading status, progress, ownership, favorites, rating, dates, rereads, and private notes.

Help Eerie stay accurate

See something wrong?

Eerie ID

Reports enter a private editorial review queue. Nothing you submit changes a Book automatically.

Your dark romance companion

Keep Eerie on your home screen

Install Eerie Efficiency through your browser. Your existing account works here; you may need to sign in again in the app.

iPhone or iPad

  1. Open this site in Safari.
  2. Open the Share menu, then choose Add to Home Screen.
  3. If shown, leave Open as Web App enabled, then tap Add.

Android

Open this site in Chrome. Tap the browser menu, then Install app or Add to Home screen, if available.

Computer

In Chrome or Edge, look for the install icon near the address bar, or use the browser’s app installation menu. Options vary by browser.

If you opened Eerie inside Facebook, Instagram or another app, first open it in Safari or Chrome.

Books, searches, quizzes and your library need an internet connection. Your private reading information is not saved for offline viewing.